Emmy Long Shots We’re Cheering For: Why Matlock Deserves a Nod

Emmy Predictions Deliver Unexpected Twists — Could Matlock Be 2025’s Dark Horse?

As Emmy nomination voting wrapped up on June 23, insiders and critics submitted their final ballots, with the usual frontrunners grabbing headlines. But amid the buzz, a few surprises are quietly gaining momentum — and none more so than the unexpected resurgence of Matlock.

Yes, Matlock — the classic courtroom drama — is back, revitalized with a bold new direction and a powerhouse performance at its center. The reboot isn’t just relying on nostalgia; it’s positioning itself as a worthy contender in the 2025 Emmy race.

Matlock’s Return — and Emmy Resistance

This time around, Oscar-winner Kathy Bates steps into the shoes of Madeline Matlock, a modern reimagining of the iconic lawyer once portrayed by Andy Griffith. Bates infuses the character with razor-sharp intelligence, dry wit, and an unwavering sense of justice. Her portrayal isn’t just compelling — it’s transformative.

Yet despite its strength, Matlock faces an uphill climb with Emmy voters who’ve historically overlooked network procedural dramas. As Debra Birnbaum of Gold Derby aptly put it, “Matlock might just be the case that changes that bias.”

Procedural shows have long been sidelined in awards conversations — a trend increasingly out of step with today’s TV landscape. Recent critical darlings like Poker Face and The Residence have helped shift the tide, proving that quality storytelling isn’t exclusive to streaming platforms. Matlock is poised to join their ranks.

Kathy Bates Deserves a Fresh Spotlight

Though Kathy Bates is no stranger to accolades, her performance in Matlock stands out even in an illustrious career. Her portrayal blends grit and empathy, delivering emotional and intellectual depth in every scene. Whether dissecting complex legal arguments or portraying quiet moments of vulnerability, Bates is magnetic.

This role goes beyond courtroom theatrics — it’s a profound commentary on age, wisdom, and justice in modern-day America. Bates makes it clear that experience isn’t a relic of the past — it’s a formidable asset. Her work in Matlock deserves to be part of the Emmy conversation.

Why Matlock Resonates in 2025

The reboot doesn’t just pay homage to the original; it actively engages with contemporary issues. From corporate corruption to systemic inequalities in the justice system, Matlock handles real-world topics with nuance and integrity.

While some still dismiss procedural dramas as formulaic, Matlock proves that structure can be a strength — providing a solid foundation for layered storytelling and complex character development. This is procedural TV at its finest: sharp, relevant, and meaningful.

A Strong Ensemble and Sharp Writing

The show’s success isn’t resting solely on Bates. Matlock features a rich supporting cast and a roster of standout guest stars that give each episode its own flavor. The ensemble chemistry — much like that seen in fellow CBS hit Elsbeth — enhances the show’s appeal and emotional impact.

Both Matlock and Elsbeth challenge the outdated idea that network dramas lack prestige. With high production values, dynamic performances, and smart writing, they’ve earned critical acclaim and loyal audiences alike.

Time for the Emmys to Take Notice

As the July 15 nominations approach, hopes are high for a few surprises — the kind that remind viewers and voters alike that great television can come from anywhere. Matlock may not have the flashiest campaign, but it’s one of the most deserving.

With its timely storytelling, commanding lead performance, and clear creative vision, Matlock makes a strong case for inclusion. It’s time Emmy voters recognize the evolving TV landscape and celebrate excellence — no matter the platform.

Let Matlock be that surprise. Let Kathy Bates take her well-earned bow. And let the Emmys finally deliver justice — on and off the screen.

ALSO READ

Clare Yardley Departs BMF After 10 Years to Join Enigma as Head of Creative Services